Who Wins That · Episodes

Christians vs Catholics: Who Has More Money?

Christians vs Catholics: who has more money in America? Here, Christians means Protestants and the other non-Catholic churches. Three rounds, real numbers, one winner.

Out · 1:06 Short · 3 rounds

Christians
Catholics

The scorecard

  1. Round 1

    Homes making $100,000 a year or more

  2. Round 2

    What the churches take in a year

  3. Round 3

    Giving to church, per family that gives

Every word of the Short

Who has more money? Christians versus Catholics. Three rounds. Real numbers.

Round one. They say Protestants have the work ethic that built capitalism. A German sociologist, nineteen-oh-five. Homes making a hundred thousand a year or more. Christians: about twenty-seven percent. Catholics: thirty-one percent. Pew, twenty twenty-five. So much for that work ethic. The Catholics take it. Ninety-five points.

Round two. They say the Vatican is loaded. Over five thousand properties. What churches take in a year, in America. One Catholic parish: about half a million. All twenty thousand: about ten billion. Christian churches are smaller, but there are over a quarter million. About forty-five billion. The Christians take it. Ninety-five points. Tied. One round left.

Last round. They say Catholics give less in the collection plate. That one's true. Giving to church, a year, per family that gives. Catholics: thirteen hundred seventy-two dollars. Christians: twenty-eight hundred nine. Twice as much. The Christians take it. Ninety-five points.

Final. Christians one hundred ninety, Catholics ninety-five. Who Wins That. The Christians win. But one Catholic parish takes in three times a typical evangelical church. A scoreboard counts dollars. Not faith. Follow Who Wins That to be a winner.

Sources

Every number in this episode comes from these sources, as listed under the Short on YouTube.

  1. Household income from Pew Research Center's Religious Landscape Study (2023-24, published 2025).
  2. What congregations take in from the Hartford Institute for Religion Research ("Finances and Faith", 2024).
  3. How many congregations from the 2020 U.S. Religion Census (ASARB, 2023).
  4. Giving to religion from the Giving USA Special Report (2017), as reported by Religion News Service.
  5. The work ethic idea from Max Weber ("The Protestant Ethic and the Spirit of Capitalism", 1905).
  6. The Vatican's properties from APSA's 2024 report, as reported by Catholic World Report and Hurriyet Daily News (2025).
  7. The collection plate claim from David P. King of the Lake Institute on Faith and Giving (2017).
  8. The non-Catholic share of $100,000 homes and both sides' church totals are worked out from those numbers and marked as the ref's estimate on screen.

More matchups

Show all
Roblox vs Minecraft vs FortniteWho Wins That episode cover: Who Has More Friends? Roblox vs Minecraft vs Fortnite4 roundsTaylor Swift Fans vs BTS FansWho Wins That episode cover: Who Has More Money? Taylor Swift Fans vs BTS Fans4 rounds
Trump vs Putin vs Xi JinpingWho Wins That episode cover: Trump vs Putin vs Xi Jinping: Who's the Best Minecraft Player?Coming
Gamers vs AthletesWho Wins That episode cover: Gamers vs Athletes: Who Has Higher IQ?Coming
Indonesia vs Malaysia vs SingaporeWho Wins That episode cover: Indonesia vs Malaysia vs Singapore: Who Wins a Blindfolded Fistfight?Coming
Democrats vs RepublicansWho Wins That episode cover: Democrats vs Republicans: Who Commits More Crime?Coming
Korea vs Japan vs VietnamWho Wins That episode cover: Which Country Has the Fastest Finger Dexterity? Korea vs Japan vs VietnamComing
Mr Beast vs Elon MuskWho Wins That episode cover: Mr Beast vs Elon Musk: Who Has More Social Impact?Coming